,

What makes a great Performance Development Review?

What do we mean by Performance Development Reviews?

Performance Development Reviews (PDRs) are sometimes considered an old fashioned term, however for many organisations, they are the cornerstone of the performance review process. In our experience the term Performance Development Review is more commonly used in public sector organisations including the NHS. Private sector organisations have more commonly moved towards the term performance appraisal or performance management process because these are seen as less backward looking, with more of a focus on ongoing feedback.

Now if you want to understand more about the difference between performance appraisal and performance management you can read our blog post here. However, for the purpose of this article we are going to clarify the subtle difference between performance reviews or appraisals and a PDR. So, in our experience organisations that use the term PDR are trying to emphasise the development and growth opportunities that can be associated with the conversation. The purpose is more about engagement and retention of staff by identifying areas for growth and career opportunities. There will be some conversation about goals and hoe people overcame their biggest challenges that year, but because the appraisal usually doesn’t/cannot link to pay or reward then the focus should be more about the indivdual’s progress. So that’s the purpose – it isn’t always the reality, read on to find out how you can show your organisation how to approach performance development reviews.

Why are Performance Development Reviews important?

A Performance Development Review (PDR) serves as a dedicated opportunity for managers to engage in meaningful discussions with employees about their professional growth and development needs. It is an essential way of motivating top performers and fostering a culture of continuous improvement.

The key benefits of PDRs include:

  • Making direct reports feel valued and invested in.
  • Driving employee engagement and motivation.
  • Building confidence in newly acquired skills.
  • Identifying continuous learning and development opportunities.
  • Providing support and fostering optimism for career progression.
  • Facilitating open discussions on roles and future career ambitions.

By structuring PDRs effectively, organisations can ensure that development remains a priority and that employees receive the necessary support to thrive in their roles.

How to Run a Performance Development Session

There is no one-size-fits-all approach to PDRs. However, organisations can follow some best practices to maximise their effectiveness.

1. Schedule PDRs at Strategic Intervals

Many organisations only carry out annual reviews, often as part of a formal review process. However, this can make development feel like a reward or substitute for a salary increase rather than an ongoing process of individual and organisational growth.

We recommend conducting PDRs at least three months into the year. This allows managers to track progress against objectives set at the start of the year and take corrective action if employees are falling behind. Additional check-ins, such as a mid-year or nine-month review, can further reinforce the importance of continuous development.

To the right, we have our Actus model showing how you can achieve year-round performance conversations and include performance development reviews. Certainly, this model can be adapted to suit your business needs. For example, you could have a performance development review at the mid-year appraisal or at the 9-month mark too!

2. Incorporate Constructive feedback

PDR’s do need to be carried out on an ongoing basis and individual objectives should play a part in these conversations. It is logical that development should be aligned with skill gaps or help the individual achieve their performance metrics or goals. Development shouldn’t be completely detached from the performance conversation or appraisal process. It should fit into one overall whole which has a strong focus on helping the individual to develop and grow, but is also an opportunity to provide feedback.

 

3. Document Conversations and Make Them Accessible

Busy schedules can lead to forgotten conversations, which may result in missed development opportunities or miscommunications about career progression. Documenting PDR discussions ensures continuity and accountability. Sometimes difficult conversations need to take place, making sure these conversations are captured means that line managers can have full confidence that the message was received and hopefully the individual’s performance is going to be back on track.

A good performance management system, such as Actus Software, enables managers to record these conversations and access them easily when needed. This helps HR teams track employee growth and identify internal talent for promotions or new roles.

4. Include All Team Members in Development Reviews

A common misconception is that personal development should only be provided on a ‘business needs’ basis. While it is essential to align development opportunities with strategic goals, excluding certain employees can lead to disengagement and stagnation. Development Reviews should be offered consistently with balanced feedback and growth opportunities available to everyone.

Remember that development methods can extend beyond traditional face-to-face reviews. Organisations can leverage digital tools, webinars, and virtual training sessions to ensure equal access to learning opportunities. Can you offer secondments, more responsibility or on the job learning by involvement in specific projects? Thinking creatively about development options can be really helpful.

Did you know that Actus regularly offers free webinars, podcasts, videos and a wealth of free development resources that your people can access?

Watch our Webinar: How to Conduct a Remote Development Session

 

5. Foster a Culture of Serious Commitment to PDRs

PDRs should not be treated as a ‘tick-box’ exercise of employee evaluation. Instead, they should be viewed as a valuable opportunity to enhance employee engagement, talent retention, and confidence building.

To maximise impact:

  • Schedule PDR meetings in advance and allocate dedicated time for them.
  • Ensure both managers and employees come prepared with relevant discussion points.
  • Maintain an open and constructive dialogue, focusing on strengths, challenges, and aspirations.
  • Follow up on agreed development actions to demonstrate commitment and accountability.

If either party appears disengaged, it diminishes the value of the process. Therefore, organisations should cultivate a workplace culture that prioritises employee development as a strategic objective.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid in Performance Development Reviews

While PDRs offer numerous benefits, several common mistakes can undermine their effectiveness.

1. Conducting Reviews Infrequently

Annual PDRs, while better than none, often lead to outdated objectives and limited development tracking. A continuous feedback culture, with quarterly or biannual reviews, ensures real-time progression.

2. Lack of Employee Preparation

Employees should be encouraged to prepare for PDRs by reflecting on their achievements, challenges, and areas for improvement. Providing them with guiding questions or a structured template can make the process more effective.

3. Failure to Follow Up

A PDR without follow-up actions is ineffective. Clear, documented action plans should be reviewed periodically to track progress and ensure accountability.

4. One-Sided Conversations

PDRs should not be solely manager-driven. Employees should have the opportunity to voice their aspirations, concerns, and feedback on how the organisation can better support their growth.

The Business Benefits of High-Quality PDRs

Well-executed PDRs offer significant advantages for businesses. These include:

1. Enhanced Employee Performance and Productivity

Regular development discussions help employees understand expectations, receive guidance, and improve their performance. By identifying and addressing skill gaps early, businesses can prevent underperformance and boost productivity.

2. Improved Employee Retention and Engagement

Employees who feel supported and valued are more likely to stay with an organisation. High-quality PDRs demonstrate an investment in professional development, reducing turnover rates and increasing long-term commitment.

3. Stronger Talent Pipeline and Succession Planning

Through structured PDRs, businesses can identify high-potential employees and create clear career development pathways. This strengthens succession planning and ensures that leadership roles are filled internally when vacancies arise.

4. Increased Organisational Agility

A workforce that continuously learns and adapts is more agile in responding to industry changes. PDRs encourage ongoing professional development, equipping employees with skills that support business growth and innovation.

5. Better Communication and Team Collaboration

Encouraging open dialogue between managers and employees fosters a culture of trust, transparency, and collaboration. Employees who regularly discuss their progress and goals are more aligned with the company’s strategic direction.

What can go wrong with PDRs?

Despite good intentions, many organisations struggle to implement PDRs effectively. Here are some common problems and how to overcome them:

1. Overly Generic Conversations

Some PDRs become superficial, with vague discussions that fail to address specific performance issues or development goals. Managers should have the communication skills to provide balanced feedback and tailor conversations to each employee, focusing on concrete achievements, challenges, and personalised development plans.

2. Inconsistent Approach Across Departments

If managers adopt different standards for PDRs, the employee experience will be inconsistent and has the potential to turn performance reviews into opportunites for cynicism. Organisations should establish clear guidelines, provide training for managers, and use performance management software to standardise the process.

3. Lack of Actionable Outcomes

A PDR without tangible follow-up actions is ineffective. Managers should ensure that each review is a wway to monitor progress and results in clear, actionable steps that are documented, tracked, and revisited in future discussions.

4. Fear of Honest Feedback

In some organisations, employees hesitate to share honest feedback due to fear of negative repercussions. Creating a safe, open environment where employees feel encouraged to express their thoughts leads to more constructive PDR discussions.

5. Viewing PDRs as a Compliance Exercise

If PDRs are conducted simply to ‘tick a box,’ they will not yield meaningful results. Businesses should integrate PDRs into a broader culture of development, where feedback and career progression are ongoing priorities.

Conclusion

Performance Development Reviews are a vital tool in fostering a high-performance culture. By conducting PDRs at regular intervals, recording discussions, including all employees from top management down, and ensuring commitment to the process, organisations can drive engagement and career growth.

Leveraging technology, such as Actus Performance Management Software, further enhances the efficiency and impact of PDRs by enabling structured, ongoing performance conversations and goal tracking.

If you want to learn more about conducting effective remote PDRs, watch our recent webinar: How to implement continuous performance management

Additionally, download our free manager’s guide to setting objectives: ‘7 Simple Steps to Setting Objectives’ to support managers in creating meaningful development plans.

How Actus Performance Management Software Supports PDRs

Actus performance management software is designed to embed SMART principles into your organisation’s processes. With the ability to set, track measurable objectives and review objectives, Actus ensures your goals are Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant and Time-bound. The software facilitates continuous performance conversations, real-time feedback and reporting, so you can monitor progress and adjust objectives as needed. By using Actus you can increase employee engagement, accountability and overall performance so your organisation stays on track to achieving its goals.

The company has evolved over the past 12 years, starting with pure performance management. Then building out our own fully integrated talent, learning, compliance and feedback functionality. We also have API’s to link to payroll/HRIS systems. This means you can start with Actus as a software solution for your initial requirements. With full confidence that this can evolve over time to address future strategic requirements with fully integrated add on modules. With the same great customer service!

Take a quick look at the Actus system tour here:

3-Minute System Tour3

Book a demo and discussion with one of our expert team who can outline how Actus can address your people challenges and will walk you through Actus Performance Management software:

Request Actus Software Demo

Actus believe in a better workplace for people, to support Managers in the Appraisal process, we have a free manager’s guide “7 Simple Steps to Setting Objectives” available to download here:

Download 7 Simple Steps Manager’s Guide

Actus offers more than free HR resources and great performance management software. Our team of organisational development consultants can help with your performance management needs or smart goal setting requirements and we also have a podcast called ‘The HR Uprising’ which has a variety of informative topics in business and HR. Please visit the HR Uprising website link below, or download wherever you get your podcasts from (YouTube, Spotify, Apple, Audible etc).

HR Uprising Podcast episodes

HR Uprising listen on Spotify Apple YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts

If you enjoyed this blog and would like to read more on this topic please see here.

And if you are thirsty for more please see below how our Software can help you…

Actus offers a complete performance, talent and learning platform

Quick 1 minute summary of Actus Software

    Not quite ready for a Demo?

    Please complete the details to receive a 3 minute system tour direct to your inbox!

      Request a quote today

      If you are looking for performance management software for 1000+ employees get in touch for a quote today.

        The 360 Tool for Independent Consultants

        Talk to one of our partnership specialists today.

          Not quite ready for a demo?

          Fill in your details below and then please check your email for a link to the 3 minute overview of Actus Software

            Get in touch with us today!

            If you have any questions, enquiries or just want to say how much you like us (or what we can do better), please drop us a line.